Map Wars IV: The Minister Strikes Back

In earlier blog posts, we’ve discussed the resurrection of the plates for the 1833 MacRae-Brazier map and their use by Wellington Williams to publish a “new” map of North Carolina in 1854. The following episode involved their use by an unknown publisher (J.H. French?) for a bizarre map that turned out to be a publisher’s mock up for the map that is the subject of today’s post. What does a minister have to do with all of this?

 

Samuel Pearce was born in Truro, Cornwall, UK, in 1807. The Dictionary of North Carolina Biography(1) reports that he came to the U.S. (Virginia) at an early age and was eventually ordained as a Methodist minister. He gave up the life of a circuit-rider when he settled in Hillsborough in 1848, though he continued his calling as a minister. Pearce also briefly operated a school and was an agent for northern book publishers. In 1852, Pearce, Calvin Wiley, and William Cooke began collaboration for the publication of a new map of the State to be accompained by a gazetteer. We’ll save most of the details of that project for another day. Suffice it to say that Wiley dropped out very early to pursue other interests and Cooke and Pearce apparently had different visions for their enterprise. Cooke announced the dissolution of his partnership with Pearce almost simultaneously with his announcement that the map had been sent to the publisher to be engraved. Pearce didn’t let this minor setback dissuade him. Unable to copy Cooke’s map, he resorted to the still breathing MacRae-Brazier plates. Samuel Pearce’s wall map of North Carolina, embellished with more than 20 beautiful vignettes was published in 1860. (Conclusive proof of the map being published by 1860 has been found; 1859 ads for the map are ambiguous as to whether or not the map had been published at that time.)

PearceMapImage

 

On Pearce’s map, many of the New York vignettes included on the publisher’s mock up map have been replaced by vignettes of buildings in North Carolina and the District of Columbia, and several North Carolina natural landmarks, such as Pilot Mountain. However, there are still a number of unlabeled vignettes at the bottom of the map that represent buildings in New York. For example, one building has “Dr. J. Trissler” above the portico. The home and office of Dr. John Trissler was in Vienna (Phelps), Ontario County, NY.  To zoom in up close on these vignettes, try here (more user friendly) or here (more reliable).

The following 1860 advertisement describes Pearce’s map as “very handsomely gotten up.”

18601218CarolinaWatchman6PearceMaps

 

The editors of the Raleigh Register state that everyone should own a copy of the map:

18600111RaleighRegisterPearceBestMapPubished

These advertisements do not refer to the accuracy of the map, and with good reason. The 1857 Cooke map was unquestionably a more accurate map, being an entirely new map rather than a recycled and minimally updated 1833 map. Perhaps this was a factor in the legislature’s rejection of Pearce’s request that the State purchase copies of his map for the common schools. With only two known surviving copies of Pearce’s 1860 map (Library of Congress and State Archives), one can safely assume that very few readers took the Raleigh Register’s editors’ advice.

Comments or questions are greatly appreciated. Tell us “What’s on your mind” below.

(1) see http://ncpedia.org/biography/pearce-samuel for biographical information on Samuel Pearce; however, the information it provides on Pearce’s maps is not reliable.

One thought on “Map Wars IV: The Minister Strikes Back

What's on your mind?